Residents oppose sewage treatment site near UVic; rally set for Wednesday

A trio and their dogs traverse a popular trail in Haro Woods. Photo © VibrantVictoria.ca.
A stretch of green space bordering the University of Victoria has been identified as a future site of a sewage treatment facility by the Capital Regional District’s sewage treatment plan. But according to nearby residents, Haro Woods, which covers an expanse nearly one kilometer in length between Cedar Hill Cross Road and Sinclair Road in Saanich, is no place for sewage treatment.
A website has been setup by residents who are advocating for the transformation of Haro Woods from a parcel of land with future development potential to a public park. SaveHaroWoods.ca, operated by Deborah Dickson, claims that a sewage treatment plant is not the most prudent use of the land and in the event of a spill at the treatment facility, wildlife and a nearby children’s hospital could be affected. “If there was to be a raw sewage spill, say like the one that just happened in Halifax or say, what happened in Hamilton – you would see that not only is the land at risk, but the marine environment that includes the JPod Orcas. Consider a major sewage spill dumping through the children’s hospital 100 meters from the proposed site,” Dickson wrote on VibrantVictoria.ca’s discussion forum.
In response to the forces trying to save the green space from development, VibrantVictoria.ca discussion forum member “Bernard” suggested that if residents wish to preserve the land from development, they should come together and offer to buy it (the parcel is currently owned by the University of Victoria, the municipality of Saanich and the Queen Alexandria Foundation). “…we have to keep in mind that the land is not public lands set aside for public enjoyment or preservation,” Bernard wrote, and added that if “50 houses in the area took out a $100,000 second mortgage, there would be more than enough money to buy the lands.”
The issue of sewage treatment and the location of treatment sites has been contentious since the early days of the sewage treatment debate. Faced with well over a billion dollars in start-up and operating costs and on-going maintenance costs thereafter, many residents have been up in arms over sewage treatment plans that according to some scientists are completely unnecessary given the treatment already in place and the characteristics of the Straight of Juan de Fuca. Others claim that the dumping of sewage into the open waters is an embarrassment and could have long term environmental repercussions.
Meanwhile, supporters of the initiative and taxpayers upset over plans to force sewage treatment across the capital region are staging a rally on the steps of the legislature this Wednesday, March 17th at 2PM.
To discuss the Save Haro Woods initiative on the VibrantVictoria.ca discussion forum click here. To discuss sewage treatment in the capital region, click here.
Copyright © 2010 by VibrantVictoria.ca. All rights reserved.
Responses to this Headline or Article
The five most recent replies to VibrantVictoria.ca's discussion forum's Save Haro Woods initiative against sewage treatment site thread, the most relevant thread to the above headline or article:
Chris J
Jun 24, 2010 at 1:48 pmok, I just read in the Vic News that these storage tanks are going to be put in the Haro Woods. Now, unless the CRD has figured out a way to get these underground tanks in without cutting down trees, it seems premature to declare the woods 'saved'. What do people think? Any details available on how big these tanks might be?
edit: And I just found the A News video from two weeks ago that reported that there will be pumping stations in the woods. Pumping stations and storage tanks without cutting trees or displacing wildlife and creating an invasive species 'edge effect' in the rest of the woods. Good luck. Saved is actually not at all what I would consider this.
VicHockeyFan
Jun 25, 2010 at 10:12 amQuote: ok, I just read in the Vic News that these storage tanks are going to be put in the Haro Woods.... Good luck. Saved is actually not at all what I would consider this.
Quote: However, underground storage for overflows will be implemented. The CRD doesn't currently have any plans of installing the tank â€" or tanks depending on the volume â€" in the Haro Woods area either.
Saanich News.
Bingo
Jun 25, 2010 at 2:49 pmI don't see the logic in storing all the crap at Haro Woods. I suppose it is easy to get it there, because all the land around the woods is higher. But if you then have to pump it somewhere else, everything is up hill.
Why don't they put the storage tanks at the nearby University of Victoria, and convert all that nice sludge into electricity.
Cadborosaurus
Feb 10, 2011 at 6:28 amQuote: Wasn't it around then that the whole "Mystic Vale" controversy was in full swing? My memory is hazy.
No it was not. The height of the uproar surrounding the Mystic Vale issue was from the early 90s to August 10, 93 when UVic bought the shares of the two companies, Sherwood Oak Estates Ltd and Bay Meadows Estates Ltd, which owned Mystic Vale. The companies were owned by the late John Byron Price (1917-Sept 15, 2010) when UVic bought the vale from him.
The Commonwealth Games event was in 94 and student housing (cluster or dorm) had nothing to do with the Mystic Vale issue. So far, I have been referring to the Saanich part of Mystic Vale. The Oak Bay portion, is a different story.
This is not well known but the Oak Bay part of Mystic Vale was approved for development in 1962. Fortunately, the plan was thwarted by luck when UVic purchased the CJVI property (which included the Oak Bay part of Mystic Vale) from the Island Broad Casting Company Ltd in 1964. Had it been developed, saving Saanich's Mystic Vale would have been pretty much pointless.
Yaser Mohammed
University of Victoria Sustainability Project (UVSP)
phx
Dec 02, 2011 at 10:51 pmQuote:
Here in Victoria we have the Panama Flats situation. The farmer wants to grow berry crops and Saanich wants him to allow his land to be flooded all winter. Saanich should buy him out if the floodplain issues are important to the local government.
And Saanich has done just that, to the tune of $2.4 million. Frank Leonard says: "...it's important agricultural land, in fact we'll put
Uhm, yeah... :rolleyes:



