The first design wasn't terrific to begin with but I think it had a few things going for it and it probably could have worked. However, (shock and surprise) the CoV's recent advice has now taken the design in a much blander direction. No more strong vertical lines, and an exaggerated emphasis on the small punched windows and dreary plain panel surfaces.
Par for the course, really. I wish I had invested in plain cladding panels in ~2015 because the CoV's promotion of them on major buildings would have made me a fortune by now.
Seriously, in recent years the CoV's design advice seems to be about producing "after" images that look way more raw and unrefined than the "before" images ever did. To do this even one time would be pretty crazy, but to be doing it consistently is cuckoo bananas with nuts on top.
--