It's a little off-topic as it's for Vancouver, but I think it is something worth watching to see what happens.
A woman sipping a drink while pushing a stroller, a senior walking with a cane, and several patrons at a McDonald’s scattered with fear as a flare exploded inside a busy Vancouver mall, fired by a man with a long history of violence, severe mental illness and drug addiction who was trying to escape a botched theft.
You have two "sides", with one wanting a firm approach to be proposed this fall to Vancouver city council;
MacEwan, who works at both St. Paul’s Hospital and the UBC psychiatry department.
MacEwan has teamed up with Mike Harcourt, a former B.C. premier and Vancouver mayor, and others,including Ethel Whitty and Jacquie Forbes Roberts, former heads of the city’s homelessness and community services departments, to come up with a plan they will present to Vancouver city hall this fall.
“I’ve certified people for having addictions. Some doctors don’t agree with it,” he said.
It’s a difficult conversation to have, he says. No one wants to further stigmatize marginalized people, and research has shown those with serious mental illness are far more likely to be the victims of violence than perpetrators.
But it is not helpful, he said, to pretend that the needs of this population can be met by simply providing them with a room in social housing. “We have to deal with these people because, yes, they are dangerous.”
The other side wants more of the same.....
Janice Abbott, who oversees several social housing buildings as executive director of Atira Women’s Resource Society, has spoken to MacEwan about his proposals, and agrees there is a group of people in the Downtown Eastside who desperately need more help. But she argues hospitalization is not necessarily the best way to help a person with a severe mental illness.
“I agree absolutely that there is a group of folks here who are not getting the services and support they need. Where I diverge is how do you provide that support? And I’m not sure it’s all about psychiatry,” said Abbott
While Abbott says she respects MacEwan and his efforts, she believes the solution to these problems lies more with a safe drug supply, guaranteed annual income and ending violence, in addition to providing sufficient housing.
“If you don’t address those root causes with improved drug policy, with an improved social safety net, how do we know who really needs to be committed? Because it’s not all about psychiatry, its also about trauma and systemic oppression.”
I am not sure I understand what Abbott means when she calls a "safe drug supply" a root cause and not mental illness.
Edited by On the Level, 25 July 2020 - 05:17 PM.